From the GiveWell Blog, check out this interesting post on the way in which aid agencies are feeding off of the Japan emergency to stock their coffers. There’s more elsewhere.
The bigger issue, though, isn’t whether Japan needs the money or not. The bigger issue is integrity. Mercenary fundraising by NGOs marks our descent into the sort of fine print tactics one expects from a used car company. NGOs have abandoned ethical standards and constructed a legally defensible escape clause, usually well hidden compared to the appeal itself, basically saying that any unused funds for Japan will be used elsewhere. In the world of supermarkets and department stores, this is the bait & switch tactic. Advertize a huge sale on an item, get people into the store, then switch. “We’re sorry, that item has sold out, but you might be interested in…”
We should ask NGOs: Right now, what percentage of the collected funds do you reasonably expect ever to go to Japan? Is it even 50%? In the end, the genuine outpouring of empathy for Japan will pay for office furniture in quite some other locations. One might have expected more from the self-proclaimed moral leaders of the world.